
UPDATE (November 2011): I know, I know, I'm grasping at anything for credit and kudos. It's kinda pathetic. But the melting snowman cookie that has gone viral? This is the original, made by yours truly. I'm still waiting for some sort of paycheck or windfall of riches...
how to make a melting snowman cookie
Oh, poor snowman. If you don't like the sentiment this expresses, you'll see I've added the option of making your snowman smiley. That way, it will appear the snowman understands his inevitable demise and doesn't mind so much the nature of things.
you will need:
dough
frosting
Americolor soft gel pastes (Bright White, Orange, Electric Green or any color for buttons)
sharp knife
frosting bag with 4 tip
small spatula or knife
white rolled fondant
Black Americolor gourmet writer
light corn syrup
optional: frosting bag with 2 tip, Chocolate Brown soft gel paste (can also use a black or brown gourmet writer)
notes on supplies: You can also substitute concentrated pastes for the soft gel pastes, but I much prefer Americolor, as they are tasteless. Concentrated pastes, the frosting bag and tip, the rolled fondant, and maybe even the gourmet writers are available at major craft stores. Or, check on the Americolor site for links on the many, many places you can buy on the internet.
step one: bake your blob cookie
Roll out your dough and cut out a blob shape with a sharp knife. I drew my shape first on paper and cut around the paper. Don't make the blob too big, about 4 inches. If the edges are rough from cutting, pat with your fingers to smooth. Bake on a parchment paper lined baking tray and let cool.

step two: frost your blob
Color some frosting with the Bright White gel paste and fill the bag with the 4 tip. Outline cookie with frosting and let set a good half hour. Take some frosting in a bowl, color white and add water, little by little, stirring until it's syrupy. Pour the runny frosting onto the middle of the cookie and spread to the edges with a small spatula or butter knife. Let set til firm a good two hours, even longer if possible.

step three: make your snowman parts
Take a few teaspoons worth of fondant, knead (you can add a few drops of White coloring to brighten) and roll between your palms to form a sphere. If the fondant gets too sticky, let it sit for ten to fifteen minutes. Set on a piece of parchment or wax paper to harden for about an hour. Do the same with the carrot and buttons. Knead a small amount of fondant with the Orange color and form a triangle with your fingers. Set on the wax paper so the tip of the carrot points upward. Knead any color into fondant and roll small spheres for your buttons.

step four: make your face
When the snowman head has dried til firm enough to write on, make your face with the black edible gourmet pen. Choose from smiley (happy about melting) to shock (not happy about melting).
step five: assemble your snowman
To adhere the fondant pieces to each other and to the cookie, dab your finger in light corn syrup and rub on the areas that will be adhered. Start with the head and press firmly but gently onto the blob. Next, attach the carrot to the face. Then the buttons. For the sticks, I used brown frosting in a bag fitted with a 2 tip and piped. But you can also just draw them on with a brown or black edible pen.
What a wonderful idea! Brilliant!
ReplyDeleteBut you knew that already.....lol
Nice cookie humor.
This is sooo cute! It is perfect for a Californian like me!
ReplyDeleteThis is so cute! I love it!
ReplyDeletetoo freaking (can I say freaking?) cute!!!!
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely freekin adorable!!!! I LOVE THIS!!!! I will definitely have to make some of these!!
ReplyDeleteomgod that is soooo adorable!
ReplyDeleteWahaha! that cracks me up! I love it!
ReplyDeleteI love it!!! I remembered Calvin and Hobbes snowmen when I saw these cookies in your blog, it's a great idea.
ReplyDeleteHilarious! I am going to have to try making these. My kids would laugh themselves silly.
ReplyDeleteOMG, how adorably funny! I can just imagine my kids having fun making these.
ReplyDeleteI love it!
ReplyDeletehaha those are great! Could do the same for the wicked witch in Wizard of OZ. Very creative!
ReplyDeleteThese are so absolutely adorable and creative. You know this idea will be stolen and reused in elementary school bake sales everywhere!
ReplyDeleteoh my, this is the cutest cookie i have EVER seen! I am definitely bookmarking this page for future reference-so so cute!
ReplyDeleteWhat a super creative and super cute idea, I love it!
ReplyDeleteThanks for allll your lovely comments! Mr. Melty seems to have struck a chord out there.
ReplyDeleteFound you via food gawker. Your little guy's adorable. And the novice baker/decorator appreciates the step-by-step instructions.
ReplyDeleteThis is the cutest thing - EVER. I had to call my mother in FL and made her go to foodgawker to show her. Cutest cookie I have EVER seen! What an imagination! I'll be checking your blog from now on - Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely the cutest thing I ever saw in a cookie!
ReplyDeleteThanks everyone for your super lovely fabulous comments! Means so much to me (just in case you're back on my blog reading comments....)
ReplyDeleteYou are so my cookie hero. I'm posting this on my blog and linking back to you. I hope that's okay. (It will be up Monday)
ReplyDeleteYummyyyyyyyy
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for posting such great directions. I've always wanted to make cute iced sugar cookies, but have never had any success. I made these and they turned out perfect! I will be checking back soon and rushing to buy your book!
ReplyDeleteThis is a great cookie for Houston, Texas. If the high only gets to 70, we think we are in the depths of winter!
ReplyDeleteI will make these for a holiday party this weekend. But, I will purchase cookies (maybe a flower-shaped sugar cookie) and use white malted milk balls for the head. (I'd rather sew than cook.)
Thanks for the idea.
Absolutely adorable, I'll save this to make with the little "grands"!
ReplyDeleteSorry to hear your cookie was plagiarized. Some people have no shame. The watermark is a good tactic.
You are so talented what a great idea . I have to send cookies back to my family in California and when they open the box to see these they will crack up! Thanks so much for the creative idea.
ReplyDeleteHi these are great, i made these with the kids and then made melting snowman cuppies for school which went down great there was nearly a stampeed we had teachers from other classes coming in to pinch some x.
ReplyDeleteHappy Christmas
http://make-happy.blogspot.com/2010/02/melted-snowman-cookies-valentine.html
ReplyDeleteTried to let this gal know about your design... I am just so irked by how Stacey is stealing your idea!! I left her a few more comments which never made it to publishing.
She must feel guilty!!
For good reason.
Blessings-
Amanda
These are completely adorable!!!
ReplyDeleteWow! Thanks for such an excellent idea! I made these and posted them on my blog:
ReplyDeletehttp://cursesandblast.blogspot.com/2010/12/oh-snowmanity-i-found-this-adorable.html
They were a such a big hit, thanks again!
I know this was an old post, but I still featured it today in my snowman post. Thank you for sharing =)
ReplyDeletewww.purplepaisleypinwheels.com
I comment on almost nothing, but this is really, really awesome!!!
ReplyDeleteI just found this and had to share on my facebook page! Love the warped sense of humor!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.facebook.com/pages/AdoraBelleDesign/267785176073
I love them, I can't wait to make! Thank you for this my daughter will love it!
ReplyDeleteThese are fantastic! I can hardly wait to make them with my wee girl! Looking forward to seeing what other fantastic treasures you are offering! Many thanks!
ReplyDeleteI live in the Philippines and a couple of years ago, gave away all my snowmen ornaments as I felt they were totally inappropriate for a tropical Christmas. Fortunately many friends disagreed with me, so they all went to good homes! However I must say, that I would allow your melting snowmen into my house, as I feel they are totally in keeping with our tropical climate!
ReplyDeleteThese are SO adorable! My entire house is decorated in a snowman theme and these cookies would be great to serve at my party!
ReplyDeleteBrilliant!!!
ReplyDeleteThese are amazing! I almost never make decorated cookies (in too much of a hurry to eat them) but I might have to make an exception for these.
ReplyDeleteVery cute cookies! I was just wondering what type of cookie or cookie dough was used for these and is it also posted?
ReplyDeleteAw, thank you all for the new and updated comments! And for finding such an old post in blog years :)
ReplyDeleteAnonymous, click the "dough" or "frosting" in the ingredients list and you will go to the recipe!
Oh benevolent cookie goddess, please help me! I want to make some snowman cookies to send to my brother, who's stationed in the Middle East (get it? snowmen in the desert?). I saw a recipe for using partially-melted marshmallows stuck on frosted sugar cookies and wondered, will the heads stay attached during shipment? What's the best way to safely ship "fancy" cookies like this? THANK YOU!
ReplyDeleteExcellent question KatrinkaJane! I'm going to email you right now, cuz it's a long answer :)
ReplyDeleteI'm wanting to make these cookies but I want to use candy instead of fondant... but I can't think of anything to use for the head :( any ideas?
ReplyDeleteKeely, I've seen lots and lots of versions with marshmallows! perfect canvas for that. Or a pop-em doughnut?
ReplyDeleteJust love your idea. It's spectacularly original and completely adorable. For what it's worth, I've had credit posted since I was first informed of who the original creator was. I'm very sorry that I seem to have caused such a problem.
ReplyDeleteAw, thank you Stacey! I actually see that as a true courtesy, even, considering you didn't even know the design came from me at first :) And I'll say it over and over, as a little blue as it makes me to see this cookie everywhere just for the whole wanting-attention thing, of course of course, I wouldn't ever place blame on all those innocent people who just want to bake some melting snowman cookies with no ill-will whatsoever!!
ReplyDeleteMy only grump comes from those specific folks who, for example, took my photo and entered it in a contest. Or the person who copied my exact tutorial down to the green fondant button and fondant carrot and then lied about it, or the company who "told" me they were taking my copyrighted photo for their promotion materials and there was nothing I could do about it (that's what spurred my recent post). Really? All you great folks out there with heart and consideration, you are not part of my diatribe :)!!!
AMAZING!
ReplyDeleteA version of your idea made the WIN blog.
ReplyDeletehttp://winblog.org/?p=3909&cpage=1#comment-2933
:)
shared your link.
Sanne
Thanks Sanne!! It's crazy, I'm still seeing versions everywhere. Who knew?
ReplyDeleteugh, I keep forgetting to sign in with the right me. That's me up there, on my other acct!
ReplyDeleteAwesome - my family are gonna love this cookie
ReplyDeleteIf it's any consolation, I prefer your version ;-)
ReplyDeleteif it helps, yours is the first Mr. Melty I've seen and fabulous. I'm going to try it and give them as holiday gifts for the teachers...but I think I might use a cake pop for the head b/c I don't love the taste of fondant...so fear not: you are MY first Mr. Melty and I'm greatful.
ReplyDeleteThanks! Oooh, cake pops, perfect choice!
ReplyDeletelove it! off to the store ;)
ReplyDeleteLove it! Was going to try to do the Ninjabread cookies but this one looks like more fun. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteHi and a HUGE hug to you for this cookie idea and the instructions! I've never made royal icing before yesterday. God bless you for your recipe! Your Sugar Cookie recipe is also GREAT!
ReplyDeleteI'm attending an annual cookie exchange today, and I usually take something very safe/easy to make. today I'll be going with 6 dozen melting snowmen cookies.
I have to admit, it took me most of the day, yesterday, to make them...but they're adorable and so worth it! I'm sure they'll be the "belles of the ball" today.
And...having never done decorated/flooded cookies in my life...I'm hooked! I can't wait to get your book/books! Love making adorable cookies. Now to perfect all the techniques! Thanks again!!!!!
Wow, Debbie, you have no idea how impressed I am! Flooding and cookie decorating kinda takes awhile to get the hang of, so I can't believe you made 6 DOZEN! For an EVENT! I guess after 6 dozen you're an expert now though. (6 Dozen!!?!? Wow.)
ReplyDeleteOn Friday, I volunteered at the Snowball Express gathering at the Kansas City airport. Families and kiddos of fallen soldiers were gathered for their flight to Dallas. A grandma of one such little guy brought cookies based on your design! Yesterday I made them to take to a holiday party. Just wanted to say thank you for such a fun idea and also wanted to let you know they were shared at an event that warmed lots of hearts. Thank you!
ReplyDeletethe perfect snowman cookie to make in australia where a real snowman would definatly melt at christmas
ReplyDeletethese look amazing!! really want to have a go at making them myself! great idea! xx
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your idea with us! I made these to take for our party at work today. I will definately be telling everyone I found this on your website. It was so clear and easy to follow. My 6-year-old grandson enjoyed making the fondant hats and mittens and dressing the snowmen. xoxo carol
ReplyDeleteThank-you for sharing your idea! My son will love these.
ReplyDeleteRegardless that it is getting stolen, it is an awesome idea. It's cooler that you shared it with everybody. Thank you for that.
ReplyDeleteI LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this cookie. Mr. Melty is the cutest darn cookie I have ever seen. I just read your post about not getting credit for him. It sickens me that people can be so underhanded as to steal an amazing idea from you and call it their own. Give credit where credit is do. Also, Nobody should have their hearder say HOME of the original ____________ Snowman Melted Cookie Period! Just because a person adds or changes something using Your design, doen't make it thier original idea. I am so Happy you posted about this. I am Glad to know YOU are the mastermind behind the masterpiece..You are the ONLY home of Mr. Melty. The Original! Keep up the amazing work. I LOVE your Blog.
ReplyDeletesniffle, sniffle, thank you Lisa!!!
ReplyDelete